To the Editor:
Teaching is a relationship, first among teacher and students, and then among those who surround that primary relationship. Because the most significant aspects of human relationships cannot be quantified, it is disconcerting to read that the Alliance for Excellent Education is proposing that teaching 鈥渂e defined primarily by the measurable contributions that teachers make to student learning,鈥� according to your article 鈥淭est Students to Enrich High School Teaching, Brief Urges鈥� (April 2, 2008). The alliance would include other factors鈥攊f, that is, they can be counted with standardized tools.
It is true that some aspects of the teaching-learning relationship can be measured. But as Albert Einstein reportedly said, 鈥淣ot everything that counts can be counted, and not everything that can be counted counts.鈥� In the case of schools today, focusing on the countable will only intensify the damage now caused by high-stakes testing. While the alliance calls for using multiple assessments, those, too, would be standardized. The proposal also supports the latest silver bullet, 鈥渧alue added,鈥� in which 鈥渧alue鈥� is but a multiple-choice test score.
U.S. education is increasingly controlled by standardized testing, from incessant 鈥渋nterim鈥� and 鈥渂enchmark鈥� testing, to high-stakes graduation tests, to the No Child Left Behind Act. If the Alliance for Excellent Education鈥檚 agenda succeeds, that which is immeasurable but profoundly important will continue to disappear from our schools. Testing already sucks the life out of thousands of classrooms, with low-income and minority-group students suffering the most. Ironically, in this intense period of measurement, even gains on standardized exams such as the are slowing.
Public anger over NCLB鈥檚 testing regime is rising together with the intensity of testing. The question is whether teachers, parents, students, civil rights and religious groups, and community leaders will be able to halt the drive to reduce schooling to the easily measurable before the educational landscape becomes a desert.
Monty Neill
Deputy Director
National Center for Fair & Open Testing
(FairTest)
Cambridge, Mass.
